Final set of comments.

http://psuc97.wordpress.com/2012/03/25/is-it-possible-to-measure-every-single-variable/#comment-36

http://poeycheung.wordpress.com/2012/03/25/is-it-ethically-okay-to-use-internet-sources-as-data-for-qualitative-studies/#comment-42

http://saspb.wordpress.com/2012/03/25/convicted-on-statistics/#comment-56

http://re3ecca.wordpress.com/2012/03/21/employability-correlation-and-causality/#comment-84

Manipulation is such a strong word to use, providing a large quantity of negativity surrounding the idea. Just because something has been manipulated it does not necessarily mean it’s for the wrong reasons. If you think of a person trying to lose weight this would be viewed as manipulation of their diet in an attempt for a desired outcome of weight loss. This manipulation can in-aversively lead to several other positive outcomes including self-esteem and self-perception. This example highlights how manipulation for a desired outcome can not necessarily imply a corrupt method, but identify a potential level of control needed to be applied to generate the required results.

There are few cases within Psychology whereby limiting the amount of participants has been seen as a requirement for an investigation. Through a large sample size investigators have the ability to increase the level of validity through a higher percentage of measuring what was originally intended, increase reliability with a larger sample provides more supporting evidence and also have the potential to achieve a more representable sample of the population. With these scientific aspects becoming more apparent it appears unjust to categorise this method as ‘bad science’. Although it appears dishonest to potential manipulate the outcome it is not only the overall results benefitting, the scientific merit of the investigation is also increased by achieving other scientific requirements. Therefore with all these positive outcomes of this action should it really be looked down on?

In comparison adding participants also prolongs the duration of the experiment providing competing studies to succeed, allows more data to be analysed and the higher possibility of individual differences playing a role. Manipulating data as an overview reflects badly upon the field of psychology as a whole but also brings to questioning other investigations integrity therefore should be avoiding at all costs to maintain the clean image this field holds.

 

Case studies are an intriguing example as to how effective a small participant sample can have a large impact upon the field. Using either 1 or a small number of volunteers, case studies provide a more in-depth investigation into the specific individual/s allowing a more detailed report to support results. Baring this in mind it goes to show regardless of the participant number an effect can be presented with even the smallest amount of applicants therefore increasing this could result in a Type 1 error. Overall if there was an effect then surely it would have been presented without the necessity for increasing participant numbers.

In conclusion with such time, effort and investment put into the investigation surely it should be more valuable to the investigator to discover an outcome based on the correct hypothesis and method taken rather than manipulating the data. Something gained honestly is more rewarding than cheating the system to gain what you want. Following procedure and maintaining the image of psychology and avoiding type 1 errors would be the correct method rather than manipulating data.

Links for week 8 comments:

*  http://psuca8.wordpress.com/2012/03/11/is-applied-psychology-is-more-valuable-than-theoretical-psychology/#comment-69

*http://poeycheung.wordpress.com/2012/03/11/the-methodology-of-the-most-recent-sona-study-that-i-have-been-a-participant-for/#comment-34

*http://ohhaiblog.wordpress.com/2012/03/11/facebook-and-syphilis-are-they-linked/#comment-77

*http://psuc3d.wordpress.com/2012/03/11/blog-due-11032012/#comment-49

Psychology use a variety of methods from observational to statistical methods to quantity variables allowing a decision to be drawn based on these figures. Measures can be produced to represent the variable however there can be some doubtfulness in the justification of the degree.
Validity is the technique of measuring what was originally intended to be measured in the early stages of an investigation therefore without validity research can be rendered unhelpful. So clearly there is a cause for determining factors and the effects of which they inflict however not all figures can be measured.
A common misconception of the image of a psychologist is the ability to read people’s minds. In reality this idea is an unrealistic theory however observations both conscious and unconscious may contribute to a just decision but no such ability of mindreading is involved. The ability to read peoples thoughts is one the ideas that not only psychologists cannot measure but also humans. A person’s thoughts and mind is both a conscious and unconscious being which varies between individuals suggesting even if a method could be acquired to achieve this a measureable scale could not be calculated based on the level of individual differences. From this it can be recognised that there are some forms in which psychologists cannot measure and also some forms which have been misrepresented by the implied measure.
Ainsworth & Bell (1970) is a prime example of an effective measure used within psychology. Developing a scale consisting of type B, type A and type C attachments, Ainsworth & Bell produced a measureable scale of secure and insecure attachments basing their research on 100 middle class American infants and their mother figure. Factors such as attachment although a difficult area to categorise is an example of one of the many influential measurements used by psychologists.
Within memory the capacity in long term memory store is classified as infinite although this is a measure it is also a rather vague scale of measurement. It could be suggested there is a defined number ranging between individuals, which is just too large to calculate therefore the term infinite is applied to resolve confliction upon the matter providing a generalised measurement. Within a research topic this level of applying value would not be accepted method. It can be seen that although it lacks evidence this measure is agreed upon by most psychologists raising the question is long term memory classified as a measured aspect or merely collective idea?
Some people say a picture is worth a thousand words maybe something cannot be achieved in words and therefore should not be confined to a definition or a measure as sometimes the best thing about an entity is not being able to full understand it. Baring this in mind although some may view the inability to measure certain mechanisms, such as thoughts, as an negative it may not be a restriction upon the field but a constraint on the ability to appreciate the present context.

These links involve the comments I have left for week 5, semester 2:

What to do if you find an unsignificant result!

http://gabrielradzwan.wordpress.com/2012/02/17/is-there-anything-that-cant-be-measured-by-psychologists/#comment-32

http://ellies1mpson.wordpress.com/2012/02/17/faking-it/#comment-64

http://danshephard.wordpress.com/2012/02/19/sona-for-the-students-or-for-the-staff/#comment-32

With society ever advancing, methods of data collecting have been presented with the option of partaking within these changes, allowing a more technological approach to research investigations such as use of the internet. Some researchers look upon these methods as ethically unsound and an unprofessional manor of data collection, these researchers favour developed theories such as observational and direct methods of examination.
Internet sources can consist of a variety of context for example established papers, journals and case studies can be made accessible online to use as data however there is also the internet it’s self as a method of communicating to participants as a technique of data collection such as surveys with even the prospective of video interviews.
The American Psychological Association (APA) in 1973 provided the exploratory community with a set of standards and principles in which needed to be taken into consideration to provide a just method of investigation, these standards not only protect the participant but also the researcher. The summary of ethical guidelines consists of 10 main principles which all investigations have to meet in order to gain ethical approval for the analysis to commence, a full list of these principles can be found at the following link: http://www.apa.org/ethics/code/index.aspx.  Not to undermine any of the principles but we are going to concentrate on 5 of these standards as a focus point to investigate whether any of these could be an issue with using internet sources as data and as a data collection method.
Informed Consent is an agreement between the researcher and the participant indicating that they are fully aware of what to expect and are happy to continue in aiding the researcher to contribute to the experiment. If the data collection was published upon the internet, making the material accessible openly the researcher will have had to make this clear to the participant, ensuring both before and after this investigation that they are consenting to their section of data to be accessible publically with a final review before publication. In this case the information has already undergone informed consent from the participant, with referencing addressing the consent of the researcher so in this case ethical guidelines are maintained and provides a simply method of accessing consented data.
Confidentiality addresses the same issues as informed consent through publication rights however the only difference involves the reproduction of personal information in an indirect system. If data is reproduced then the same level of confidentiality needs to be maintained if not stricter however if a direct route is taken the high level of confidentiality needs to be maintained such as not revealing personal information a possible solution could be persona names.  Despite publication the individuals has the right to confidentiality regardless of the level of directness.
As for deception, debriefing and protection of participants as there is no direct contact between the investigation and the individuals themselves these guidelines do not come into question as an in-direct method of investigation have been taken. On the other hand a direct method of technological data collection such as online questionnaires would need to include a debrief to explain what the examiner is investigation, how the data will be used and addressing how no harm will come to the participants however if emotional disturbing questions are asked then the researcher may provide information on qualified services to approach these issues. Acknowledgement that these guidelines have been taken into consideration is essential for both direct and indirect methods of data usage.

The internet provides a series of advantages to the use of data accessibility but also as a viable method of data assembly. Using the internet supplies investigator’s with a free, easy and quick method of accessing thousands of data files with the simple click of a button. As psychologist in training we are currently been made aware of the length of time and dedication that goes into a research project through online usage this could save valuable time, shortening procedures such as data input and providing more time to focus on the direct question of the project. Although the internet causes a personal barrier between the investigator and the individual this could provide a positive outcome as some participants may feel more open to express themselves through this method allowing a more qualitative and reliable data file.
In contrast the internet like other methods of investigation has some disadvantage of its techniques used. Firstly the impersonal method of collection could result in participant’s lack of concentration and inability to take the project seriously such as online surveys. This subtitle approach could be viewed as unprofessional taking a relaxed and uninvolved method of the investigation with the possibility of participants deceiving the requirement of the study could cause confounding variables within the figures. The lack of control over variables could affect the reliability and the variability of the inquiry come into question.
Overall I feel online methods of data usage and collections are viable methods of research providing an accessible and potentially a more qualitative statistics being produced. The advantages outweighing the negative for example the possibility of a minority not taking the project seriously as these could be in theory removed as outliers later in the process indicating solutions to some of the disadvantages presented. These small disadvantage’s should not overlook the prospect of a modern and interesting method of data assembly with the same guidelines met as traditional methods there produces no violation of ethical guidelines. Therefore with no ethical breach I feel there should be no restriction of using internet sources as a viable method of conducting research.
With the ever advancing world, technology has increasingly become more involved within people’s lives as well as a dependent for some.  Maybe the question should be is it ethical to restrict researchers within their field, denying them of the experience to uncover the potential that technology could aid in the researchers discovery.

The following links below provide access to the comments I have left for Semester 2 Week 3 :

*http://saspb.wordpress.com/2012/02/05/does-size-matter/#comment-36

*http://smmitch.wordpress.com/2012/02/05/why-is-the-file-drawer-problem-a-problem/#comment-58

*http://psuca8.wordpress.com/2012/02/05/are-blogs-a-useful-teaching-and-learning-methodtool/#comment-46

*http://poeycheung.wordpress.com/2012/02/05/is-the-term-approaching-significance-cheating/#comment-19

Case studies consist of an in-depth analysis of a participant or small group of participants, taking individual differences into account and with the potential for treatment to be applicable. In comparison a Single-Subject design uses a single participant to measure change in manipulated variables to produce a cause-and-effect relationships.
On a face value level both Case Studies and Single-Subject Designs appear to have very little differences, it isn’t until the methods of investigation and clear understanding of each of these approaches that highlights the significant differences between the two.
At a glance similarity between the two approaches consists of small group of participants, having the weakness of subjective interpretation of the results as well as providing a detailed observation of the individual as a result. Baring all these similarities in mind the execution of the research is the main apparent difference between the two designs.
Within a Single-Subjects design the method of collecting data comes from a visual examination of a simple graph of data showing each measurement of the variable. With just simple measurements this indicates there are no collected data set of scores available to statistically analyse or produce methods of interpretation such a mean, averages and standard deviations. Collected data must show a clear outline of the effect from the variable in order to support the significances of the findings for others to interpret themselves.
A well-known investigation using the Single-Subjects design is Anna O. Investigating the effects of her father’s death and her recent paralysis of the limbs and speech from which the treatment was able to amend.
Contemporary Clinical Psychology by Thomas G Plante, pp 81-87 provides detailed description of the Case of Anna O along with examples of the graphs used in the Single-Subject Design.
Also the following link provides details of the investigation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anna_O.
This suggests that if the data plot of the graph is not clear enough the significance of the research will be overlooked due to the method design used by the researcher. This method provides support for the cause-and-effect relationship however I feel that relevant research maybe overlook due the graphs provided, suggesting valuable research maybe discounted based on the wrong choice of method to present the data.
In comparison to this, Case Studies do not take the objective of the cause-and-effect relationship into account in its theory, although they have been known to contribute to general laws and theories. However unlike the Single-Subject design Case Studies lack the true experimental design of research, providing the fundamental difference between the two methods. Case studies can only provide a correlation of variable with suggested treatments administered by the research and not provide a cause-and-effect between the two, although within psychology nothing can ever been 100% proven the relationship is supported by statistical methods unlike the Case Study.
Despite the lack of experimental design Case studies have also had an impact on the psychological field including such studies as Little Hans, Phineas Gage and Kitty Genovese.
Kitty Genovese is a prime example of a case study involving an attack on a young women whose investigation lead to naming of the Bystander Effect in which 38 witnesses to the crime failed to provide assistance to this young women which brought her to her untimely end despite some calls to the authority for help. Although there was no research investigation in place this case contributed to the field of psychology through the method of using Case Studies.
More information on this Case Study can be found on the Radio 4 podcast on:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/science/case_study_20080507.shtml
Little Hans contributed to supporting Sigmund Freud idea of the Oedipus Complex which had previously being discounted on the lack of evidence, Hans was the only study involving a child thus highlighting its significance to such a renowned theory.
More information for Little Hans can be found on BBC iPlayer at:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00bg335/Mind_Changers_Case_Study_Little_Hans/
From these examples of Case studies although they do not provide a distinction of effect they have enable to contribute greatly to the field of psychology indicating that despite the considerable difference Case studies provide significance to the field just as much as Single-Subject Designs.
The interpretation of the results provided by these methods serves as a main focus point of distinction but another difference lies within the methods used. Traditionally Case studies imply methods such as observations, personal interviews or surveys as well as archival data such as the Kitty Genovese case. Methods such as these provide a greater insight into the individual and take the qualitative approach to the investigation.
In comparison Single-Subject designs use the experimental designs as a form of investigation using methods including phases, Levels, Trends and stability as a measure of data such as those identified in Anna O example. Single-Subject designs appear to take a quantitate approach although there is no sets of means or other figures to take into consideration the main objective surrounds the points plotted on a graph and there indications whereas Case Studies focus more on a descriptive approach.
In conclusion the main differences between Single Subject Designs and Case Studies lies in the category of what consists of an experiment design and what does not. Single-Subject Designs provides a cause-and-effect relationship of behaviour and variables in comparison to the correlations indicated by the Case Studies. Methods also vary based on the selected research design.

Like today’s modern world the government and authorities provide a balance of law and order within our society, this idea is applied to Psychology also with ethics and research projects. The use of ethical conduct allows order within the world of research ensuring and the image of psychology to be kept at the respectable level in which it deserves.

A quote from the British Psychological Society (BPS) identifies their views on ethics as “Ethics is central to everything we do whether in research or practice”. This quote emphasis how the authority figures in this field views the topic at hand. With this ideas expressed it sets an example to fellow psychologist to keep this code in mind as the correct method for future research. With the views of the BPS and the American Psychology Association holding a similar view it would suggest that documents ethics should hinder the progress of research to ensure concordance to the psychology values. I few choose to obey the laws within society we should therefore uphold the laws in the field in which we practise.
http://www.bps.org.uk/what-we-do/ethics-standards/ethics-standards

Ethical principles consist of Deception, Debriefing, informed consent, right to withdraw, protection of participants and confidentiality as well as a few others. These guidelines are in place to protect not only the image of psychology but also the participants used in these experiments. Without the participants research would be no research projects therefore the people contributing to findings such as these deserve the upmost research and safety in research therefor suggesting that the need for documented ethics procedures should hinder research progress.

In contrast some of the most controversial research such as Milgram and Zimbardo has had the biggest impact within today’s society implying a positive result from derailing from the ethical guidelines. Milgram and Zimbardos investigations broke several ethical guidelines resulting in several issues afterwards. Without these break-through some of the valuable knowledge in psychology would not be known so one that grounds I would be persuaded to agree that guidelines should be taking into consideration separately for each investigation rather than collectively.

The following links provide my weekly comments on fellow students blogs.

http://cjcpb.wordpress.com

http://phyllislau.wordpress.com

http://gabrielradzwan.wordpress.com

http://psucb9.wordpress.com

    Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
    Start free